Textbook Resources

Chapter Activities

  • Chapter Summaries
  • Learning Objectives
  • Critical Thinking Questions
  • Multiple Choice Quiz
  • True or False Quiz
  • New to this edition
  • Feature Summary
  • Table of Contents
  • Sample Chapter
  • Book Preface
  • About the Authors
  • AP* Correlation
  • AP, Honors and Electives E-Catalog
  • Instructor's Manual
  • PowerPoint Presentations
  • CPS by eInstruction
  • True-False Quiz Answers
  • Multiple Choice Quiz Answers

British Council

Is critical thinking a western concept, by don watson, 05 march 2015 - 06:43.

'According to IBM, 90 per cent of the data in the world was created in the last two years.'

r2hox, licensed under  CC-BY-SA  and adapted from the  original .

Educators agree that critical thinking is a crucial skill for the 21st century, but is it harder to teach in some cultures than in others? Burmese educationalist Win Aung argues that critical thinking has a longer history in the East than many have recognised. The British Council's Don Watson reports.

According to IBM, 90 per cent of the data in the world was created in the last two years.

In order to make sense of this explosion of information you need to be able to tell the difference between wisdom and sophistry, between timely words of warning and interest-driven scaremongering. That power of analysis is what’s called critical thinking. It is defined by the  Critical Thinking Community  as the ability to check for ‘clarity, accuracy, precision, relevance, depth, breadth, significance, logic, and fairness’, to build knowledge from a range of sources, including your own experience.

Does an emphasis on critical analysis of information mean that one part of the world will be better equipped to learn the skills necessary for success? Received wisdom indicates that critical thinking is embraced more enthusiastically in the West than it is in the East. Politics, tradition and religion have, according to this view, formed a powerful triumvirate which conspires to leave half the world with an approach to knowledge that relies on rote learning, and regards questioning as anathema.

Dr Win Aung, a consultant with 30 years’ experience of working in education in Burma, accepts this view has some foundation in day-to-day life. It is particularly evident in a country still struggling to emerge from the shadow left by decades of authoritarian rule, but it is by no means the whole story.

‘We do have a more vertical and hierarchical model of society,’ Win Aung says. ‘Myanmar is largely still a country where the father rules in the home and the teacher rules in the classroom.’ But, he argues, the notion that critical thinking is a foreign concept is not just misguided, it is factually wrong.

‘Certainly in the Buddhist tradition, which is influential across the whole of Southern and Southeast Asia, there is a strong tradition of critical thinking. Some of the fundamental tenets of the Buddhist tradition are essentially an early version of critical thinking,’ he says. ‘The Buddha taught freedom of thought and freedom of enquiry to his disciples. The emphasis is on internal reflection and consideration of the value of a proposition, rather than on blind belief’.

So why is rote memorisation a predominant way of learning in Burma? The answer, Win Aung says, is partly down to the structure of the Buddhist religion. ‘The fact that Buddhist teachings are recorded in the Pali language, which does not have a writing system, puts a great emphasis on the ability to absorb and recite correctly, which consequently gained a value in the East that it was never accorded in the West’.

Then, in Myanmar particularly, the military government found it expedient to emphasise unquestioning obedience as a core virtue. The result is what Win Aung, drawing on Brazilian educationalist Paulo Freire, calls a ‘ culture of silence ’. We see this in the reverent atmosphere of the classroom, where students lack the confidence to question things. This is significant because a questioning behaviour could be critical if students are to get by in the world.

‘As Myanmar opens up, we have more access to the outside world. And because of new technology, the young are exposed to a sudden rush of information,’ he says. 'The ability to evaluate this critically and decide what is true and good and what is false and harmful is all the more important’.

In attempting to revive the tradition of critical thinking in Burma, Win Aung does not underestimate the scale of the cultural change that he and his fellow reformists need to effect as they begin the process of putting a national strategy for education into place.

'Many of our teachers are not critical thinkers', he says. 'We have to improve their ability to teach more effectively and be able to promote critical thinking.' This dual challenge, he points out, places a great emphasis on Burma’s current generation of teachers to overcome a lack of confidence brought about by decades of the ‘culture of silence’, and create a space in Burma’s classrooms where a culture of critical thinking can grow and thrive.

‘If the teacher exercises authority in the classroom, how they exercise their authority is very important in changing the culture of that classroom.’

There are also challenges at the societal level, he says. ‘We have a culture of harmony, which brings with it a demand for respect and obedience. When children start asking questions, there may be a feeling that they are becoming impolite and aggressive’.

According to Win Aung, the change needs to be a culturally sensitive one – a reconnection with the Buddhist tradition of critical thinking which circumstance and history disrupted.

‘We need to balance social harmony and social cohesion, and the practice of democratic education’.

Dr Win Aung is one of the policy makers from the UK and the ASEAN (Association of South East Asian Nations) countries brought together by the British Council in for the 21st Century Learning series, to share experience of their triumphs and challenges.

Find out more about the British Council's policy dialogue work and the  ASEAN deep learning policy engagement series , as the final seminars in the series take place this month.

You may also be interested in:

  • How can education prepare us for this globalised world?
  • Is China creating a workforce with no soft skills?
  • The humanities: a career path to international development

View the discussion thread.

British Council Worldwide

  • Afghanistan
  • Bosnia and Herzegovina
  • Czech Republic
  • Hong Kong, SAR of China
  • Korea, Republic of
  • Myanmar (Burma)
  • Netherlands
  • New Zealand
  • North Macedonia
  • Northern Ireland
  • Occupied Palestinian Territories
  • Philippines
  • Saudi Arabia
  • Sierra Leone
  • South Africa
  • South Sudan
  • Switzerland
  • United Arab Emirates
  • United States of America

COMMENTS

  1. 1. Critical Thinking Activity: Revolutions in the Western World I A

    Critical Thinking Activity: Revolutions in the Western World I A series of revolutions spread across the Atlantic world in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. All of them had their roots in the ideas of the Enlightenment.

  2. Solved 2. Critical Thinking Activity: Revolutions in the

    Critical Thinking Activity: Revolutions in the Western World A series of revolutions spread across the Atlantic world in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. All of them had their roots in the ideas of the Enlightenment.

  3. Solved Critical Thinking Activity: Revolutions in the

    Critical Thinking Activity: Revolutions in the Western WorldA series of revolutions spread across the Atlantic world in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. All of them had their roots in the ideas of the Enlightenment.

  4. PDF Using Historical Role-Playing Games (RPGs) to Teach History ...

    Critical thinking skills Developing arguments and using evidence Analyzing sources and bias Comparing and contrasting points of view Historical content Tensions in Boston that led to the American Revolution; Resistance to slavery in the years preceding the Civil War Labor conflicts that emerged with industrialization in the early 20th century ...

  5. READ: The Enlightenment (article)

    Between the late seventeenth and late eighteenth centuries, there was a period of rapid intellectual change that came to be known as the Enlightenment. Thinkers, writers, artists, political leaders, and also new groups of "ordinary" people drove this major cultural and intellectual movement. They believed they were finally shining the "light ...

  6. Critical Thinking Questions

    The West in the World, 4th Edition (Sherman) Chapter 17: Factories, Cities, and Families in the Industrial Age Critical Thinking Questions. The Industrial Revolution Begins; What differences between the Western and non-Western worlds may have led to the industrial revolution emerging first in the former?

  7. Is critical thinking a Western concept?

    Received wisdom indicates that critical thinking is embraced more enthusiastically in the West than it is in the East. Politics, tradition and religion have, according to this view, formed a powerful triumvirate which conspires to leave half the world with an approach to knowledge that relies on rote learning, and regards questioning as anathema.

  8. US History Critical thinking questions Flashcards

    Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like what enlightenment values are reflected in the declaration of independence, what effects did the great awakening have on anerican thought, how did the peace treaty that marked the end o the american revolution change the boundaries of the united states? which countries controlled territory on the borders of the new nation and more.

  9. World History Connected

    The Cuban Revolution serves as a central focus with an evaluation of its revolutionary impact upon the Western Hemisphere and beyond. 16 The Middle East is first appraised with an assessment of Ataturk's Turkish Cultural Revolution of westernization. The Turkish Revolution is then compared with the Iranian Revolution and the rise of Islamic ...

  10. Need Help!. 12. Critical Thinking Activity: Revolutions in the

    Critical Thinking Activity: Revolutions in the Western V A series of revolutions spread across the Atlantic world in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. All of them had their roots in the ideas the Enlightenment. Many writers fr... ... HISTORY WORLD HISTORY Answer & Explanation Solved by verified expert Rated Helpful

  11. Solved Critical Thinking Activity: Revolutions in the

    Answer to Solved Critical Thinking Activity: Revolutions in the | Chegg.com

  12. 2. Critical Thinking Activity: Revolutions in the

    Critical Thinking Activity: Revolutions in the Western World A series of revolutions spread across the Atlantic world in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuri ideas of the Enlightenment. Many writers from that period believed that power should emanate from the p nobles. These ideas altered Westem society forever. Despite this overarching

  13. Rethinking the "Western" revolution in science

    Historian James Poskett sees modern science as the product of ceaseless cross-cultural, geopolitical transformations. In his new book, Horizons, Poskett argues that the so-called "Western" revolution in science was actually the result of global transcultural and transregional interactions, all triggered by global socio-cum-geopolitical shifts.

  14. U.S. History 1: Critical thinking activity Flashcards

    U.S. History 1: Critical thinking activity. As the exploration of America was under way, important events in Europe were also unfolding. To understand and interpret the events taking place on both continents, it is important for students of history to have an understanding of chronology. Click the card to flip 👆.

  15. The Western Way of Development: A Critical Review

    con ict context where economic activity is critical to conserving any . ... story of development aid which re ects new thinking in Western societies. ... It is the Western world's .

  16. A history of western education, the modern west Europe and the new world

    The following section presents recent researches on Chinese and Western pedagogy and the definition of these two. Based on integrating Chinese and western advanced teaching principles, Chinese ...

  17. Historical Thinking Strategies

    Engage in the study of history and our present day through a critical lens. As a Museum, we are dedicated to providing the resources and support you need today, and every day, to make meaning of history with your students. Most importantly, as a history museum, we encourage the use of historical thinking strategies to engage in the study of ...

  18. 2. Critical Thinking Activity: Revolutions in the

    Critical Thinking Activity: Revolutions in the Western World A series of revolutions spread across the Atlantic world in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. All of them had their roots in the ideas of the Enlightenment.

  19. M8.3 Critical Thinking Activity: Challenges Adams and ...

    Q-Chat. 3. Critical Thinking Activity: Challenges in Jeffersonian America From 1801 to 1809, President Thomas Jefferson attempted to implement his vision for America, including fostering western expansion and creating a nation of independent farmers. His beliefs helped guide the political policies and social trends of the early nineteenth century.

  20. 2. Critical Thinking Activity: Revolutions in the Western World A

    Critical Thinking Activity: Revolutions in the Western World A series of revolutions spread across the Atlantic world in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. All of them had their roots in the ideas of the Enlightenment.

  21. World Civ Essay Questions Flashcards

    Study with Quizlet and memorize flashcards containing terms like What is meant by the term Enlightenment when used to describe a historical period? Analyze how the Enlightenment was defined both in terms of ideas and in terms of social practices, and explain the context from which those ideas and practices emerged., Although the revolutions that took place in the late-eighteenth- and early ...

  22. 3. Review activity

    Review activity - Revolutions in the Western world A series of revolutions spread across the Atlantic world in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. All of them had their roots in the ideas the Enlightenment. Many writers from that period believed that power should emanate from the people, not from hereditary kings and nobles.

  23. 2. Critical Thinking Activity: Revolutions in the Western World

    Critical Thinking Activity: Revolutions in the Western World A series of revolutions spread across the Atlantic world in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. All of them had their roots in the ideas of the Enlightenment. Many writers from that period believed that power should emanate from the people, not from hereditary kings ...